Unreality TV — What to say about gay Christians?

As a gay practicing Roman Catholic, Andrew Sullivan does not fall nicely into the media's political/religious/gay spectrum. Image from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Sullivan

As a gay practicing Roman Catholic, Andrew Sullivan does not fall nicely into the media’s political/religious/gay spectrum.
Image from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Sullivan

By Lori Heine

According to the conventional wisdom of both sides in the Duck Dynasty culture battle, Andrew Sullivan does not exist.  He is, after all, someone to whose existence neither side will admit:  an orthodox gay Christian.  Of course, these same people only recently – and very grudgingly – admitted that gay conservatives exist.  Many of the readers of this blog know that a lot of the same Americans who deny the existence of gay Christians also ignore theirs.

Thus the problem with “reality” TV.  It reflects not reality, but the unreality of what the elites believe America to be.  Phil Robertson, the patriarch of Duck Dynasty, probably doesn’t even know there are gays who are Christians – some quite orthodox in their beliefs.  That there are gay Catholics, gay Baptists, gay Pentecostals and gays who are, well, Orthodox with a capital “O.”  Or that, as many of us were raised in orthodox Christian traditions and believed our eternal salvation was at stake, we actually studied the passages in the Bible that supposedly condemn us – studied them far more thoroughly than do most of our detractors – so we know what they really say.

Reality can be messy for those who toss it aside whenever it doesn’t suit them.  Many of those who see the whole picture – instead of merely the two carefully-edited portions of it the mainstream media has shown – may be beginning to realize what is going on: that those hostile to gays want to use “religious freedom,” selectively defined, to trample gay rights, and that those hostile to religion, especially to Christianity, want to use the anti-gay prejudices of people like Phil Robertson to roll back religious influence in politics.

Once they’ve purged the political scene of gay Christians, what’s to stop them from going after gay Republicans, or gay conservatives? Even right-of-center LGBT folks who do not consider themselves religious have a stake in how this issue plays out.  If we want to break the leftist stranglehold that Gay, Incorporated has on LGBT politics, the fact that an increasing number of gay Christians are coming out – and staying in their churches – cannot be ignored.

Religion and sex are two of the most powerful emotional motivators in politics.  This is why the power-brokers play gay people like pawns on a chessboard.  It’s why so many of us report the experience of feeling pushed around, and especially of being pushed further left, politically and perhaps religiously, than we want to be.  That the “Christian” condemnation of same-sex love is actually not Christian at all cannot be overemphasized.  The obsession many heterosexual religious conservatives have with sex, particularly gay sex, borders on the pornographic.

As Sullivan notes, “This emphasis is absolutely not orthodox Christianity.  There is nothing primary about sexual sin as such in Christian doctrine.  It sure can be powerfully sinful – but it’s not where sin starts.  And to posit gay people as the true source of all moral corruption is to use eliminationist rhetoric and demonizing logic to soften up a small minority of people for exclusion, marginalization and, at some point, violence.”

Many of us find ourselves in a place we’re not comfortable being.  Nor can we afford to get too comfortable with the gains we’ve made in society in recent years.  If we don’t want to be shoved out of the GOP, out of the church, or even out of our country, it is not yet time to rest.  The Duck Dynasty controversy makes very clear that our adversaries are not resting.

Further reading

Andrew Sullivan: http://dish.andrewsullivan.com/2013/12/19/ae-cannot-bear-very-much-reality/

General gay Christian:

Gay Catholic:https://www.dignityusa.org/

Gay Baptist: http://www.rainbowbaptists.org/index.htm/

Gay Pentecostal: http://www.t-e-n.org/

Gay Eastern Orthodox:


2 thoughts on “Unreality TV — What to say about gay Christians?

  1. OH

    Conservatism is not about any core values at all. Don’t look for your keys under the lamp just because that’s where you can see, look for your keys in places where you keys might be found. The very concept of a core value is contrary to conservatism. My 2 seconds of hard work means I am worthwhile, your 20 years of working 60 hours a weak means you’re lazy, which means you deserve the worst you can get, and I am on Medicare. There’s Conservatism – and it was right where you left it all along.

  2. OH

    Core values are for people, people are lazy and deserve to die, therefore, core values are worthless. If core values were important, then people would be important, you couldn’t throw people away if they were important – so isn’t it better to have values you can throw away? Isn’t hypocrisy itself a value? Values are at best only worth what superior people use them for in the moment they are useful.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s